Send Your Wishlist Before Black Friday, Not After

There is a timing mistake almost everyone makes with holiday wishlists, and it is not leaving it too late to be delivered. It is leaving it too late to be useful.

A very large share of holiday gift buying now happens in the last week of November. If your list turns up on December 10th, the people buying for you have already bought. They bought something reasonable, at full price or nearly, having guessed. Your list arrives as a document describing what they should have bought.

Send it before the sales, and the same money buys more of what you actually want.

What to do this week

  • Build the list now, not perfectly. Ten real items beats thirty aspirational ones
  • Put a wide price range on it. Someone spending $20 and someone spending $200 are both looking at the same list and both need somewhere to land
  • Be specific about the variant. Size, color, model. Sale season is exactly when a near-miss gets bought, because the near-miss is the one that is discounted
  • Note the acceptable substitutes. "Any color", "the previous model is fine" — this is what lets someone act on a deal without checking with you and ruining the surprise
  • Send it before the sales start, with a sentence saying why: "sending early so you can catch anything on sale"

Why a link list is the right format for sale season

Because the buyer needs to be able to move fast and independently. A list they can open on a phone, in a store, at 6am, without signing into anything, is a list that gets used.

On MakerManifest each item is created from a product page URL, so the entry shows the actual product. It spans stores, which matters more in November than any other month — the same item is on sale at different retailers on different days, and a wishlist locked to one store cannot express that. Put the item on the list once and let whoever is buying find the best price on it.

Publish it and you have one link. No account needed to open it, nothing to install.

A note on prices

Be a little careful about writing prices into your notes during sale season, because they change daily. Better to note the constraint that does not change — the size, the model, the "any of these three" — and let the buyer see the current price on the page.

The duplicate risk, which is higher this week

There is no way for a buyer to mark something as taken, so everyone sees the same list. That risk goes up during a concentrated buying window when several people might act on the same day. It is on the roadmap. Until then: ask people to send you a message when they buy something, and edit the list as you hear.

The list outlives November

Whatever nobody buys is still a list of things you want, and it is already built. Keep it, edit it through the year, and it is ready for a birthday without a second thought.

A free account gives 10 lists of 25 items. If you want the dashboard to stay out of the way entirely, pick Just lists at signup — what that changes. And if you are choosing between this and an Amazon wishlist, the honest comparison is here.

Build your list free and send it before the sales, not after.

Ready to get started?

Get started →